What Consumer Reports Covers in Auto Insurance Reviews
Consumer Reports evaluates auto insurance by testing real‑world claims, pricing, and service quality. They look at liability limits, collision and comprehensive coverage, uninsured/under‑insured motorist protection, and optional add‑ons like roadside assistance. The goal is to give drivers a clear picture of what each policy actually covers, beyond the headline premiums.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Key Coverage Categories Compared
1. Liability limits: the maximum payout for bodily injury and property damage.
2. Collision: repair or replacement after a collision with another vehicle or object.
3. Comprehensive: protection against non‑collision events such as theft, vandalism, or weather damage.
4. Uninsured/under‑insured motorist: coverage when the at‑fault driver lacks sufficient insurance.
5. Additional riders: gap insurance, rental reimbursement, and accident forgiveness.
How Coverage Is Tested
Consumer Reports uses a standardized claim scenario for each state. They file a simulated claim with each insurer, then track response time, claim settlement amount, and customer satisfaction. The results are scored and displayed in a comparison chart, making it easier to spot which policies offer the most comprehensive protection for the price.
Interpreting the Results
Higher scores usually mean faster service and more generous coverage limits. However, a top score does not guarantee the lowest premium. Drivers should weigh the premium against the coverage level that matches their risk profile.
Choosing the Right Policy Based on Your Needs
• If you drive an older car: consider a lower collision deductible or comprehensive limits that match the vehicle's value.
• If you live in a high‑crime area: look for strong theft and vandalism coverage.
• If you often travel out of state: ensure the policy includes out‑of‑state liability and roadside assistance.
Consumer Reports' Rating Scale
The rating ranges from 0 to 100. Scores above 80 indicate strong overall performance. Below 60 may signal gaps in coverage or poor customer service. Use the score as a quick filter, then review the detailed coverage breakdown.
Final Tips for Selecting Coverage
1. Match liability limits to your assets: higher limits protect against large lawsuits.
2. Compare deductibles: lower deductibles increase premiums but reduce out‑of‑pocket costs when a claim occurs.
3. Verify state requirements: some states mandate minimum coverage that may affect the comparison.
4. Read the fine print: exclusions for natural disasters or specific vehicle types can alter the actual protection.
5. Use Consumer Reports' comparison tool: input your state and vehicle details to generate a personalized list of insurers with the best coverage mix.