How Consumer Reports Rates Auto Insurance
Consumer Reports evaluates auto insurance companies based on three core dimensions: customer service, financial strength, and value. They conduct surveys of policyholders, analyze claim handling times, and use industry data to assess each insurer's financial health. The resulting score is presented as a letter grade, with A+ representing the highest overall performance.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Key Areas of Assessment
- Customer Service – response time, clarity of communication, and satisfaction with claim resolution.
- Financial Strength – ratings from agencies such as A.M. Best and Moody's, indicating the insurer's ability to pay claims.
- Value – a comparison of premiums to coverage, including discounts and policy features.
How to Use the Review in Your Decision
When selecting a policy, look beyond the overall grade. Compare the specific scores for customer service and financial strength to ensure the insurer can support you when you need them. Also review the value section to see how the premium aligns with the coverage you require.
Where to Find the Review
Consumer Reports publishes its auto insurance ratings on its website and in its annual insurance guide. The online version includes interactive tools that let you filter results by state, coverage type, and budget. You can also print the guide for reference while shopping.
Additional Tips
Pair the Consumer Reports rating with other resources: state insurance department ratings, independent consumer reviews, and direct quotes from insurers. This layered approach helps you confirm that the chosen company offers reliable coverage and solid customer support.